Active-Steps-Treadmill-vs.-Sidewalk

Active Steps: Treadmill vs. Sidewalk

Where Should I Run?
If you are a runner or jogger, you may have wondered if running on the treadmill is as effective as running outside. Running or jogging is considered vigorous-intensity activity which means that you are breathing hard and fast and are not able to talk easily.(1) It is a simple and effective way to improve cardiovascular fitness and can be done outside or inside, if you have access to a gym or a treadmill in your home. Can we get the same benefits whether we run outside or on a treadmill?

Analyzing Effort and Speed
Studies show that runners expend more effort when propelling themselves on a running path than when aided by a treadmill belt. Because the belt moves, it assists the leg and makes it easier to push off the back foot.(2) According to news service BBC, a study done by Exeter University found that running outdoors required a greater effort but that runners could mimic the effort of outdoor running by using a 1% incline on the treadmill. The BBC also cited a study from Singapore that found when runners attempted to match their speed outdoors to their treadmill speed, they were slower on the treadmill even though they thought they were running just as fast.(3) If you choose to run on a treadmill, you may want to use an incline and gently increase your speed to get the same health benefits.

Weather Acclimation and Well-being
Running outdoors can provide hidden benefits. Weather varies each day and it may be physically beneficial to experience the various conditions outdoors. Running with wind or rain can be different than the climate-controlled gym or home. Temperature differences may also pose problems if you are used to running in the A/C. Running in all types of weather prepares your body for changing conditions and won’t leave you in shock when you are running out of the norm. In addition, studies suggest that exercising outdoors can improve mental health, decrease depression and stress, and elicit satisfaction.3 An enjoyable exercise routine with positive benefits can also make you more likely to exercise.

Talking About Safety
Even with their benefits, unpredictable outdoor conditions can pose some risks. If you live in a high traffic area with poor pathways or high crime, you may benefit from treadmill running. Running on a treadmill is also thought to be easier on an existing injury because of the additional “give” it has over a concrete sidewalk.(2) (Important note: Consult your physician or other health care professional before starting or altering any fitness program.)

In conclusion, running outdoors and on a treadmill each pose unique benefits and draw-backs. If you’re looking to prepare for a race, running outside may provide practice in situations you may face on race day. If the weather or area of town is unaccommodating, running on a treadmill may help you avoid these setbacks for a less stressful run. No matter the situation, finding an exercise routine that works for you is always the best option.

By Haley Jones, Tulane Dietetic Intern
June 2017

References:
1. Center for Disease Control and Prevention. How much physical activity do adults need? Center for Disease Control and Prevention Web site. 2015. Accessed October 31, 2016.
2. Paul S. How Effective is Treadmill Running Compared to Running Outside? Runner’s World Web site. 2016. Accessed October 31, 2016.
3. Is it better to run outside or on a treadmill? BBC Web site. 2016. Accessed November 1, 2016.

(Photo courtesy of CDC Public Health Image Library. Active Steps is a recurring feature that appears in the Tulane PRC’s e-newsletters and covers fitness and physical activity tips. If you have any suggestions for Active Steps topics, please contact Naomi Englar at nking2@tulane.edu or 504-988-7410.)

Topics:   physical activity , running , sidewalks , built environment

Other Related Posts

Message-from-the-Director

Message from the Director

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

As I am sure most of our readers know by now, the Tulane Prevention Research Center (PRC) will not be funded for another five years. This is very sad news for all of us here at the School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, but I am sure it is just as saddening for those of you who have worked with us and partnered with us for the past 20 years. Yes, the PRC has…

Read More

Health-Racism-and-Communication-Seminar-Series

Health, Racism, and Communication Seminar Series

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

Starting this month, Tulane PRC will co-host the Spring 2019 Health, Racism, and Communication Seminar Series in collaboration with The Center of Excellence in Maternal and Child Health (CEMCH) and The Mary Amelia Douglas-Whited Women’s Community Health Education Center (MAC).  This seminar series works to educate attendees about communicating the influence of racism on health. 
 On Tuesday, March 19, Nicole Deggins, CNM, MSN, MPH, Founder and Director of Sista Midwife Productions will address Social…

Read More

Associations-Between-Neighborhood-Park-Quality-and-Usage-Findings-from-a-Tulane-PRC-Study-

Associations Between Neighborhood Park Quality and Usage: Findings from a Tulane PRC Study

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

In efforts to better understand factors that may impact physical activity levels of people in their neighborhoods, a study was done through the PRC to evaluate park quality and usage in lower income African American neighborhoods in New Orleans.   Based on prior research, neighborhoods have been classified as an important social determinant of health. “Neighborhood environments can play a role in one’s decision to engage in physical activity. Prior research has shown that lower…

Read More

Community-Partners-Update

Community Partners Update

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

Bunny Friend Neighborhood Association (February 16th, 2019) On February 16th, the Bunny Friend Neighborhood Association hosted a green infrastructure workshop in partnership with Water Wise Gulf South at St. Mary of the Angel’s Church. The Green Infrastructure 101 Water Wise Workshop taught community members “do-it-yourself” solutions to reduce flooding while leaving the neighborhood looking beautiful. The event provided refreshments and raffle prizes, including rain barrels and a home assessment for Upper 9th Ward residents. Infrastructure…

Read More

Legislative-Update

Legislative Update

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

New Orleans Food Policy Committee is very pleased with the changes recommended by the City Planning Commissions Small Box Store Study. The recommended changes make it much more accessible for residents to access fresh food while also giving food businesses and farmers an economic boost. For more information or to read through the report, check out the City Planning Commissions website or click here While the entire document is very interesting, the recommendations begin on…

Read More

Staff-Update-David-Roston

Staff Update: David Roston

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

We are excited to share that David Roston is the new Communications and Disseminations Coordinator for the Tulane PRC. David graduated with a Bachelor’s of Arts from the University of Michigan with a degree in Screen Arts & Cultures and Master’s of Public Health from Tulane University School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine. David has an extensive history of working on local and international documentary films and is interested in fusing arts and media…

Read More

Active-Steps-Avoiding-the-March-Fall-Out

Active Steps: Avoiding the "March Fall Out"

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

The start of the New Year is often seen as a time to revamp and refocus one’s attention and time on health and exercise. Unfortunately, most people fall into a so-called ‘March fall-out’ after just a few weeks of hard work at the gym. According to the Washington Post, gym attendance significantly increases in the December, January, and February months, but starts to decrease in just a few weeks leading into March. Luckily, there are…

Read More

Nutrition-Bites-Mindful-Eating

Nutrition Bites: Mindful Eating

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

Most of the population eats to eat. We are good at it, we know we need to eat in order to fuel our day, but rarely do we spend the time to savor and dissect what is being put into our mouths. Junk food and fast food are not layered with flavor and texture. They do not excite our pallet with new variety. Eating on the go leads to mindless eating and lacks emotional investment…

Read More

Nutrition-Bites-Grocery-Delivery-Service-Can-Save-You-Money

Nutrition Bites: Grocery Delivery Service Can Save You Money!

Education & Engagement

Published: March 18, 2019

Grocery store shopping can be exhausting with multiple rounds of loading and unloading groceries. Plus, the amount of time doubles when you go at the grocery store rush hour from 5-7 PM. No wonder Amazon had an estimated 18% share of online grocery delivery in 2017 with their new acquisition of Whole Foods. The future of grocery stores and how we shop is rapidly changing. Let’s talk about the perks of this method as well…

Read More

Tulane-dietetic-interns-gain-insightful-skills-in-nutrition-and-community-based-programs

Tulane dietetic interns gain insightful skills in nutrition and community-based programs

Education & Engagement

Published: December 18, 2018

This fall, 20 Tulane Dietetic Internship students gained first-hand research and health promotion experience in partnership with Tulane Prevention Research Center and local community organizations. The Dietetic Internship is a 10-month long, non-degree program offered at Tulane University that focuses on community health best practices, health promotion, and disease prevention for students seeking to become registered dieticians. As part of the Dietetic Internship, students completed a rotation with the Tulane PRC. During this time, students…

Read More

canary